The Overuse of the Term “Narcissist” and Why It Matters Clinically
By Brooke Spradlin, MS, LPC, RYT 200
Elevated Minds Counseling and Wellness
In the last few years, the word narcissist has become a common way to describe difficult people and painful relationships. It is often used to explain emotional harm, lack of empathy, or patterns of manipulation. While the desire to make sense of these experiences is understandable, the term is frequently used in ways that are not clinically accurate.
As a therapist, I see how the overuse of this label can create confusion, reinforce misunderstandings about mental health, and sometimes interfere with healing. Understanding the difference between narcissistic traits and Narcissistic Personality Disorder is an important step toward clarity.
Narcissistic Traits vs. Narcissistic Personality Disorder
Many people display narcissistic traits at times. These may include defensiveness, self-focus, difficulty tolerating criticism, or prioritizing one’s own needs in moments of stress. These traits alone do not indicate a personality disorder.
Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) is a formal diagnosis outlined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5). It involves a pervasive and long-standing pattern of behavior that typically includes:
Grandiosity and an inflated sense of self-importance
A persistent need for admiration
Lack of empathy in interpersonal relationships
A sense of entitlement
Interpersonal exploitation
A fragile self-esteem often hidden beneath arrogance or defensiveness
For a diagnosis to be considered, these patterns must be consistent across situations, present over time, and begin by early adulthood. A single relationship, conflict, or period of emotional immaturity does not meet the criteria for NPD.
Why Inaccurate Labeling Can Be Harmful
Using the term narcissist casually may feel validating, but it can unintentionally create several problems.
First, it oversimplifies complex relationship dynamics. Emotional harm can occur for many reasons, including unresolved trauma, insecure attachment patterns, poor boundaries, or limited emotional skills. Not all harmful behavior stems from narcissism.
Second, focusing on diagnosing another person can shift attention away from your own experience. Healing often comes not from identifying a label, but from understanding how the relationship affected your sense of safety, self-worth, and emotional well-being.
Finally, casual use of clinical diagnoses can contribute to stigma. Personality disorders are legitimate mental health conditions, not character flaws or insults. When diagnostic terms are misused, it can discourage thoughtful and compassionate conversations about mental health.
A More Helpful Way to Frame the Experience
Rather than asking whether someone is a narcissist, it is often more productive to ask:
Were my boundaries respected?
Did I feel emotionally safe in this relationship?
Was empathy consistently absent?
How did this dynamic affect my mental health?
Describing specific behaviors—such as manipulation, emotional unavailability, or chronic invalidation—provides clarity without relying on a diagnosis. This approach centers your experience and supports meaningful growth.
A Clinical Perspective
From a therapeutic standpoint, it is rarely necessary for a client to determine whether someone in their life meets criteria for Narcissistic Personality Disorder. What matters most is the impact of the relationship and what is needed to heal and move forward.
You do not need a diagnosis to justify ending a relationship, setting boundaries, or seeking support. Painful experiences deserve attention regardless of the label attached to them.
Final Thoughts
Language shapes understanding. Using clinical terms accurately helps preserve their meaning and supports healthier conversations about mental health.
If you find yourself repeatedly questioning relationship patterns or struggling to recover from emotionally harmful dynamics, therapy can help you explore these experiences with nuance, compassion, and clarity—without relying on oversimplified labels.
—
Brooke Spradlin, MS, LPC, RYT 200
Elevated Minds Counseling and Wellness
